This is basically regarding the Grand Slam in Men’s tennis. Men’s ATP tours feature best-of-three winners but in the Majors, it becomes best of 5. That is the long-flowing tradition. Time for a change?

Let’s look at the match between Jannik Sinner and Juan Cerundolo in the 2026 French Open, second round. The World Number 1 was leading 6-3, 6-2, 5-1. Cerundolo was serving to stay in the match – what happened next was a total shocker – from that position, the Italian Cerundolo went onto win the third set 7-5 and the further two sets 6-1, 6-1 as Sinner suffered from severe dizziness, nausea and cramps!
Let’s now talk about the 2026 US Open quarterfinal between Carlos Alcaraz and Ben Shelton. Alcaraz won the first set, while Shelton won the next two, before the Spaniard came roaring back in the fourth. Shelton eventually won in the decider, but the point in both these matches is that – had those been best of three setters, would we have seen the comebacks?
That’s the basic argument which has split the tennis world. Without a doubt, a Grand Slam match is the ultimate test of physical and mental strength. Because of the long duration, the fitter and more skilled player gets a chance to either dominate in three or recover from a slow start and win in 4 or 5 sets.
The other side of this argument is that Grand Slam matches often lead to player wear and tear. As can be seen above, from Sinner’s case, the duration of the match caused severe exhaustion. Additionally, three of the four Grand Slams – Australian, French and US – are played in excessive heat, taking a toll on players’ health.
Building further, Sinner and Alcaraz are the frontrunners of increasing number of male players pulling out of tournaments – Grand Slams and ATPs alike – due to prolonging injuries. The ATP calendar itself is pretty demanding, which causes a lot of physical and mental fatigue. As a result, players hardly get any time to recover.
7-time Grand Slam champion Carlos Alcaraz firmly believes that the Majors should be played as a best-of-five sets. He has been backed up by the latest US Open champion, Alexander Zverev. However, Daniil Medvedev is of a different opinion.
The Russian feels that a best-of-three sets would be better for the sport, in terms of fitness and career prolonging for players. If you remember the 2022 Australian Open final, which was won by Rafael Nadal in 5 sets – 2-6, 6-7, 6-4, 6-4, 7-5 – in an epic 5-hour-24-minute match against Medvedev, the first question which Daniil asked Rafa after the match was - ‘Don’t you get tired?’
This debate sprung up because of rumours going around the tennis circuit to reduce the Grand Slam matches from best-of-5 sets to best-of-3, to adapt to the hectic scheduling of matches. Remember, this is not only for players, but even the officials involved who have to spend long hours on duty with matches going late into the night.
Physical wellbeing is definitely a must – but do we compromise the legacy of the sport for the same? If scheduling is a worry, could the number of players and matches be reduced to keep the legacy intact? Food for thought.
Add Comment